AllModern Price Comparison: Which Stores Offer the Same Modern Style for Less?
Share
Stores like IKEA, Article, and Casagear can match AllModern’s clean-lined aesthetic across sofas, accent chairs, and dining furniture at prices that run 15% to 50% lower, depending on the category. AllModern sits in the mid-to-upper range of the modern furniture market, with sofas typically priced from around $800 to well over $2,000, accent chairs from $469 to $1,100, and dining chairs from roughly $90 to $430 per seat. The stores below cover the same aesthetic territory, and in most categories, they do it for meaningfully less.
How do AllModern’s prices compare to IKEA across the three main categories?
IKEA undercuts AllModern on entry-level pieces but closes the gap at the mid-tier.
Sofas
AllModern’s most popular upholstered sofas cluster between $999 and $1,499 at regular price. The Miller 84" sofa lists at $1,099, and the George 82" velvet sofa sits at $999. IKEA’s KIVIK sofa runs $799 and the FINNALA sofa is currently $1,019, so the gap on a comparable three-seat piece is roughly $200 to $300. Where IKEA pulls further ahead is at the budget end: the GLOSTAD sofa starts at $199, a price AllModern simply does not reach.
Accent Chairs
AllModern’s mid-range armchairs, including the Miller Walnut Armchair at $469 and the Rae Upholstered Armchair at $679, compete directly with IKEA’s MORABO ($399 to $499) and FINNALA armchair ($435). IKEA’s POÄNG armchair at $149 is in a class by itself for price, though the silhouette is more distinctly Scandinavian than AllModern’s broader modern catalogue.
Dining Chairs
This is where IKEA’s advantage is clearest. AllModern’s Kody Vegan Leather Side Chair runs about $99 to $115 per seat on sale, which matches IKEA’s TEODORES at around $65. But AllModern’s more design-forward dining chairs, like the Walsh Velvet at $150 to $215 per seat, are priced similarly to IKEA’s mid-tier options. Neither brand has a decisive edge here on style; it comes down to which silhouette fits the room.
| Category | AllModern (typical range) | IKEA (comparable range) |
|---|---|---|
| Sofa (3-seat) | $800 to $1,500 | $449 to $1,299 |
| Accent Chair | $469 to $900 | $149 to $530 |
| Dining Chair (per seat) | $90 to $430 | $65 to $350 |
Verdict: IKEA wins on price at every tier, but its modern aesthetic is narrower, and assembly is self-service. AllModern includes full-service delivery on most large pieces.
Does Article furniture offer the same modern look as AllModern for less?
Article sits closer to AllModern in aesthetic, and in most categories the prices are genuinely competitive rather than dramatically lower.
Sofas
Article’s sofa range runs from $799 for the Hanson 80" up to around $1,499 for leather options on sale, and full-price sofas can reach $1,699 to $1,999 for larger or premium models. That overlaps almost exactly with AllModern’s $999 to $1,499 sweet spot. The real difference is that Article carries fewer SKUs and focuses tightly on mid-century and Scandi-modern styles, so shoppers who want that specific look may find Article’s curation easier to navigate.
Accent Chairs
Article’s lounge chairs range from $299 for the Cillian on sale up to $899 for leather options. AllModern’s comparable chairs run $469 to $749. Article tends to be slightly cheaper on upholstered fabric chairs and roughly equivalent on leather. The quality gap between the two brands is small enough that price becomes the deciding factor for most buyers.
Dining Chairs
Article has a clear edge here. The Svelti dining chair is $79, the Morton and Meja are $199, and even the Everse velvet chair is $399 per seat. AllModern’s comparable upholstered dining chairs run $110 to $215 per seat. For a six-chair dining room, Article’s mid-tier options save roughly $600 to $900 over AllModern’s equivalents.
| Category | AllModern (typical range) | Article (comparable range) |
|---|---|---|
| Sofa (3-seat) | $999 to $1,499 | $799 to $1,499 |
| Accent Chair | $469 to $749 | $299 to $699 |
| Dining Chair (per seat) | $110 to $215 | $79 to $299 |
Verdict: Article matches AllModern’s mid-century modern look more closely than IKEA does, and its dining chairs are the strongest value in the comparison. Sofa prices are roughly equivalent.
Where does Casagear fit in this comparison?
Casagear carries modern and contemporary furniture across the same categories, with a catalog of 40,000+ products and free shipping across the continental U.S. For shoppers who want a wide selection without committing to a single brand’s aesthetic, it covers more ground than Article and offers competitive pricing on accent seating. The Baxton Studio Charlemagne Traditional French Accent Chair in Oak at $538.50, for example, is a fully upholstered statement chair that sits at a price point below AllModern’s comparable armchairs, which regularly list between $600 and $900 before sale. Casagear also runs regular promotions through its Special Offers collection, which can push prices further below AllModern’s everyday range.
Price, Style, and Delivery: What Actually Decides the Choice?
The gap between AllModern and its alternatives is real, but it is not uniform. On sofas, the savings from switching to IKEA or Article are modest, usually $200 to $400 on a comparable three-seat piece. On dining chairs bought in sets of four or six, the savings from Article can reach $600 or more. On accent chairs, all three alternatives beat AllModern’s regular pricing, with IKEA offering the lowest floor and Article offering the closest aesthetic match.
Delivery matters too. AllModern includes full-service delivery on most large pieces, which is a real convenience. IKEA requires self-assembly on almost everything. Article and Casagear both offer white-glove or full-service delivery options, which makes them more direct substitutes for AllModern’s overall purchase experience.
The one area where AllModern holds an advantage is breadth: its catalog is enormous, and shoppers who want to furnish an entire room from a single source will find more options there. But for buyers who know what category they are shopping and want modern style at a lower price, the alternatives above deliver.
The Savings Are Real, but the Category Matters
Dining chairs are where the savings from switching away from AllModern are largest, and Article is the strongest alternative in that category. For sofas, the price gap is smaller, and Article or Casagear are the closest matches in both aesthetic and delivery experience. IKEA wins on raw price but asks for more patience with assembly and a narrower modern aesthetic.
If accent seating is the priority, the Baxton Studio Charlemagne Traditional French Accent Chair at $538.50 is worth a look: it is a fully upholstered, wood-framed chair priced below most of AllModern’s comparable armchairs and backed by free continental U.S. shipping.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Article furniture actually cheaper than AllModern?
On dining chairs, yes, often by $50 to $150 per seat. On sofas, the prices are close enough that the difference is usually $100 to $300 on a full-size piece. Article’s accent chairs tend to run slightly lower than AllModern’s mid-range armchairs, making it a genuine alternative for buyers who want mid-century modern style without the AllModern price tag.
Does IKEA carry furniture that looks like AllModern’s modern style?
IKEA’s KIVIK, FINNALA, and MORABO lines share AllModern’s clean-lined, contemporary aesthetic. The gap narrows further at the mid-tier, where a KIVIK sofa at $799 and a MORABO armchair at $399 to $499 are credible alternatives to AllModern’s $999 to $749 equivalents. IKEA’s self-assembly requirement is the main trade-off for that lower price.
What is the best alternative to AllModern for a full dining room set?
Article is the strongest alternative for dining rooms. Its dining chairs range from $79 to $299 per seat, and its extendable dining tables start around $699. A four-person dining setup from Article typically costs $1,200 to $1,800 less than a comparable AllModern configuration at regular prices, with a similar mid-century modern look.
Does Casagear offer free shipping like AllModern?
Yes. Casagear provides free shipping across the continental United States on its furniture orders, which is directly comparable to AllModern’s free delivery policy. Casagear also offers White Glove delivery for buyers who want professional setup, a service AllModern charges extra for on some items.
How much can I realistically save by choosing an AllModern alternative?
It depends on the category. On a single accent chair, the savings range from $100 to $300. On a dining chair set of four, switching to Article can save $400 to $900. On a sofa, the savings from switching to IKEA or Article are usually $200 to $400 unless you go to IKEA’s entry-level range, where the gap can be $500 or more.
