AllModern vs Casagear: Which Is the Better Deal on Modern Home Furniture in 2026?
Share
Casagear is the better deal for most buyers shopping modern home furniture in 2026. It offers 40,000+ products with free shipping on every order to the continental U.S., no minimum purchase, and a 100% money-back guarantee, while AllModern charges return shipping fees that can reach $200 on large pieces. AllModern’s design curation and two-day delivery on select items are real advantages, but they come with trade-offs that matter once you get past the sticker price.
Both stores target the same shopper: someone who wants clean, contemporary lines without paying Pottery Barn prices. The question is which one actually costs less when you factor in shipping, delivery upgrades, and what happens if the piece doesn’t work in your space.
How do AllModern and Casagear compare on catalog size and style?
AllModern operates as a Wayfair-owned brand focused entirely on contemporary design: mid-century, Scandinavian, minimalist, and adjacent styles. Its catalog runs to roughly 10,000 items under the AllModern label, with styles filtered to stay within that modern design lane. That curation is genuinely useful if you know exactly what aesthetic you want and don’t want to wade through traditional or transitional pieces.
Casagear carries 40,000+ products across 40+ categories, covering living room, bedroom, dining, office, outdoor, and decor. The breadth means you can furnish an entire home from one store without hitting a wall in any category. The style range is wider too, which is either a feature or a distraction depending on how decisive you are.
| Feature | AllModern | Casagear |
|---|---|---|
| Catalog size | ~10,000 items | 40,000+ items |
| Style focus | Contemporary only | Multi-style, including modern |
| Categories | Furniture, rugs, lighting, decor | 40+ categories |
| Design tools | Room planner, AR visualization | Standard product pages |
For buyers who want strictly modern aesthetics, AllModern’s curation saves time. For buyers furnishing multiple rooms or mixing styles, Casagear’s depth wins.
Which store has lower prices on comparable pieces?
AllModern positions itself below West Elm and CB2, with sofas typically starting around $800 and dining tables from roughly $199 for simpler pieces. That is accessible for a design-forward retailer, though pricing on upholstered and solid pieces climbs quickly once you move past accent furniture.
Casagear’s pricing sits in a similar range. The Kive 24 Inch Counter Height Stool Chair with Black Boucle Channel Tufted Seat is $273, and the Flax 22-32 Inch Adjustable Counter Height Stool in Vegan Faux Leather comes in at $202. Those are competitive numbers for the materials involved.
On pure sticker price, the two stores are close enough that the comparison usually tips on shipping and return costs rather than the product price itself.
What does shipping actually cost at each store?
This is where the gap opens up. AllModern offers free shipping on orders over $35 within the contiguous U.S., which sounds clean. But curbside or front-door delivery is what “free” covers. Getting a piece into the room of your choice costs an extra $49.99, and full-service delivery with assembly runs $99.99. Return shipping on large furniture runs from $50 to over $200, deducted directly from your refund.
Casagear ships everything free to the continental U.S. with no order minimum and no freight surcharge waiting at checkout. White Glove delivery (two-person in-room delivery and unpacking) is available for $95 on select items. That is a predictable, optional upgrade, not a hidden fee.
| Shipping Detail | AllModern | Casagear |
|---|---|---|
| Free shipping threshold | Orders over $35 | No minimum |
| “Free” delivery type | Curbside / front door | Standard delivery |
| Room-of-choice delivery | $49.99 extra | Included in White Glove ($95) |
| Delivery with assembly | $99.99 extra | Premium Inside Delivery ($150) |
| Return shipping (large items) | $50 to $200+, deducted from refund | Covered under money-back guarantee (defective items) |
For a $700 sofa that doesn’t work in your space, a $100 to $200 return fee at AllModern erases most of the savings you thought you’d found.
Which store has the better return policy?
AllModern’s return window is 30 days from delivery, provided the item is disassembled and in original condition. Return shipping is not free. The fee depends on item size and weight, and for large furniture it regularly exceeds $50. Open-box items, clearance products, and customized purchases cannot be returned at all.
Casagear’s return window is also 30 days, but the 100% money-back guarantee means you get back what you paid on the purchase price, with no restocking fees. For defective items, Casagear covers return shipping. For non-defective returns, return shipping is the buyer’s responsibility, which is standard across the industry. The key difference is no restocking fee and a full refund on the item cost, not a partial one reduced by return freight.
Casagear Wins on Total Cost
The sticker prices are close. The shipping and return policies are not. For a buyer ordering a sofa, a bed frame, or a dining set, the true cost at AllModern includes delivery upgrades and the risk of an expensive return. Casagear’s model removes both of those variables: free shipping on every order, White Glove available at a flat rate, and a money-back guarantee with no restocking fees.
AllModern is worth considering for accent pieces, lighting, and decor, where the return risk is lower and the two-day delivery speed is a real advantage. But for large furniture purchases where the total landed cost matters, Casagear’s pricing structure is more predictable. The Casagear Living collection is a practical starting point for shoppers who want modern and contemporary pieces without the delivery math.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does AllModern charge for return shipping on furniture?
Yes. AllModern deducts return shipping from your refund, and the fee scales with item size. Small decor pieces may cost $5 to $10 to return, while large furniture like sofas or beds can run $50 to $200 or more. That cost is calculated when you initiate the return, not shown upfront at purchase.
Is Casagear a legitimate furniture store or a dropshipper?
Casagear is a U.S.-based online furniture retailer founded in 2016 in Los Angeles, with BBB accreditation, 40,000+ products across 40+ categories, and a 100% money-back guarantee. It ships via FedEx Ground for smaller items and LTL freight for large furniture, with delivery typically arriving within 8 to 12 days.
What types of furniture does AllModern sell that Casagear does not?
AllModern’s strongest differentiator is its design curation: every item fits a contemporary, mid-century, or Scandinavian aesthetic, and the site includes room planners and augmented reality tools for visualizing pieces. Casagear’s catalog is broader in style but does not currently offer built-in AR visualization tools.
Can I get White Glove delivery from both AllModern and Casagear?
Both stores offer White Glove delivery as an add-on. AllModern’s room-of-choice delivery costs $49.99, and full-service delivery with assembly runs $99.99. Casagear’s White Glove service costs $95 for two-person in-room delivery and unpacking, with a Premium Inside Delivery and Assembly option at $150 for items requiring setup.
Which store is better for buying modern bar stools online?
Both carry modern bar stools at comparable prices. Casagear’s adjustable counter-height stools, including vegan faux leather and boucle upholstered options, range from roughly $202 to $273 with free shipping and no minimum order. AllModern’s bar stool range starts around $238 for outdoor styles and varies widely by material and finish.
