AllModern vs. Casagear vs. Wayfair: Which Store Has the Best Prices on Contemporary Furniture
Share
Casagear edges out both AllModern and Wayfair on total delivered cost for contemporary furniture in 2026. It offers free shipping with no order minimum, a 30-day money-back guarantee, and a catalog of 40,000-plus products that competes directly with Wayfair in range. AllModern wins on curated modern aesthetics and occasionally faster in-stock shipping, while Wayfair’s sheer size gives it unmatched selection. For shoppers who care about the actual out-of-pocket cost after shipping and returns, the gap between these three stores is wider than the sticker prices suggest.
How do their prices actually compare on contemporary furniture?
The sticker price is the starting point, not the finish line. All three stores advertise “free shipping,” but the conditions differ enough to change the math on a real purchase.
AllModern sits in the mid-range for contemporary furniture. Sofas start around $800 and dining tables from roughly $1,200. The site runs frequent sales and promo codes, and free shipping applies to orders over $35 on smaller items. For large furniture, curbside delivery is free on qualifying items, but delivery into the room of your choice costs $49.99 extra, and full-service delivery with assembly runs $99.99. Those fees add up fast on a full room.
Wayfair spans the widest price range of the three: you can find a $39 nightstand or a $2,999 sectional, and the platform lists over 14 million items from more than 11,000 suppliers. Prices shift constantly, and sales appear without much notice. Free shipping applies to most orders over $35, but for large furniture, return shipping costs are deducted from your refund, and assembled pieces are classified as “damaged or altered,” subject to a 25% restocking fee or outright rejection. In 2026, Wayfair also removed Walmart and Kohl’s drop-off locations from its return network, making the return process less convenient than it used to be.
Casagear ships every order free within the 48 contiguous states with no minimum and no hidden fees at checkout. White Glove delivery, which includes two-person in-home placement and packaging removal, is available as an optional upgrade for $95. The 30-day return policy covers returns for any reason, with a full refund and no restocking fee deducted.
| AllModern | Wayfair | Casagear | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free shipping threshold | $35 (small items) | $35 (small items) | None |
| White Glove / in-room delivery | $99.99 | Varies by supplier | $95 optional |
| Return window | 30 days | 30 days | 30 days |
| Restocking fee | Possible on large items | Up to 25% on assembled items | None |
| Return shipping fee | Yes, on large items | Yes, deducted from refund | Covered if item is defective |
Which store has the best style range for contemporary shoppers?
AllModern’s design focus is its clearest advantage. It operates as a Wayfair-owned brand with its own catalog and identity, concentrated on contemporary, mid-century modern, and Scandinavian design. That tight focus means fewer mismatched aesthetics and a more coherent shopping experience than Wayfair’s main site. The catalog covers over 15,000 items across furniture, lighting, rugs, and decor. If you want clean Scandinavian lines at prices below Crate and Barrel, AllModern is a reasonable first stop.
Wayfair’s style range is everything and nothing in particular. The platform hosts farmhouse, mid-century, traditional, bohemian, and industrial styles simultaneously. For shoppers mixing aesthetics or furnishing multiple rooms in different styles, that breadth is genuinely useful. For someone trying to build a coherent contemporary interior, the volume can work against you. Filtering helps, but the sheer number of results can make it harder, not easier, to decide.
Casagear’s 40,000-plus product catalog spans living room, bedroom, dining, office, outdoor, and decor categories. The range covers contemporary and transitional styles across price points, and the catalog size means you can source an entire room from one place without hitting dead ends and needing a second retailer.
Pros and Cons
AllModern
- Pros: Curated modern aesthetic, fast shipping on in-stock items (sometimes two days), coherent design direction
- Cons: Smaller catalog than Wayfair or Casagear, delivery fees add up on large pieces, return shipping costs on large items
Wayfair
- Pros: Largest selection of the three, widest price range, AR visualization tools, financing options
- Cons: Inconsistent quality across suppliers, return process complicated by restocking fees and packaging requirements, overwhelming for style-specific shopping
Casagear
- Pros: Free shipping on every order, no restocking fees, 100% money-back guarantee, 40,000-plus products, White Glove delivery option
- Cons: Less name recognition than Wayfair, no brick-and-mortar showrooms, delivery typically 8 to 12 days
Does shipping speed matter enough to pay extra for it?
Buying a sofa or a dining table is not the same as buying a phone charger, and most shoppers are fine waiting 8 to 12 days if it means avoiding a $99.99 delivery fee and a complicated return process. Speed matters when it matters, and for most furniture purchases, the timeline is flexible enough that it shouldn’t drive the decision.
AllModern’s in-stock items can ship in as little as two days, which is genuinely fast for furniture. That speed has real value if you’re furnishing a new apartment on a tight timeline. But speed at the expense of a $50-to-$200 return shipping fee on a large item you end up not keeping is a bad trade.
Wayfair’s shipping consistency depends heavily on which supplier fulfills your order, and there are a lot of them. Some orders arrive quickly; others take weeks. The experience varies more than AllModern’s.
Casagear’s standard delivery runs 8 to 12 days, which is typical for online furniture retail. The White Glove option, available for $95, covers two-person delivery into the room of your choice and packaging removal. That compares favorably to AllModern’s $99.99 full-service fee, especially since Casagear’s base shipping is already free on every item.
Casagear Wins on Total Delivered Cost for Most Full-Room Purchases
Casagear wins on total delivered cost for most full-room purchases. The math is straightforward: no shipping minimums, no restocking fees, and a 100% money-back guarantee mean the price you see is close to the price you pay, even if one or two pieces get returned.
AllModern earns its place for a single accent piece under $200 where you’re confident in the choice. Its speed and curated aesthetic make it a reasonable pick in that specific scenario. Wayfair is worth checking for its sheer volume, but the return policy fine print in 2026 makes it the riskiest of the three for large purchases. When the goal is furnishing a full room of contemporary furniture where you might need to return one or two pieces, Casagear’s combination of free shipping and no-penalty returns gives it a measurable advantage the other two don’t match.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is AllModern cheaper than Wayfair for contemporary furniture?
AllModern tends to price contemporary pieces comparably to Wayfair, with sofas starting around $800 and dining tables from roughly $1,200. The practical difference is that AllModern’s catalog is more curated, which makes it easier to find modern-specific pieces without sorting through unrelated styles. Neither store is consistently cheaper across the board.
Does Wayfair charge return shipping fees on furniture in 2026?
Yes. Wayfair deducts return shipping costs from your refund on most large furniture returns, and assembled pieces may be subject to a 25% restocking fee or rejected entirely. Return shipping on large furniture can run anywhere from $50 to over $200, which significantly affects the real cost of a purchase you end up returning.
What makes Casagear different from AllModern and Wayfair for shipping?
Casagear ships every order free within the continental U.S. with no minimum order requirement and no hidden fees at checkout. AllModern and Wayfair both require a $35 minimum for free shipping on smaller items and charge extra for in-room or full-service delivery on large furniture. Casagear’s White Glove delivery is available for $95 as an optional add-on.
Which store is best if I want mid-century modern furniture under $500?
AllModern is probably the strongest option for finding curated mid-century modern pieces under $500, given its focused aesthetic and frequent sales. Casagear’s catalog also covers this price range across contemporary and transitional styles, with the added benefit of free shipping on every order and no restocking fees if a piece doesn’t work in your space.
Can I trust online furniture stores for large purchases without seeing the item first?
All three stores offer 30-day return windows, but the conditions differ. Wayfair requires items to be returned in original, unassembled condition with original packaging. AllModern has similar requirements. Casagear’s 30-day money-back guarantee covers returns for any reason with no restocking fee, which makes it lower-risk for large purchases where you’re not certain until the piece is in the room.
