Casagear vs AllModern vs Crate and Barrel: Which Store Offers the Best Value on Modern Furniture?
Share
Casagear offers the strongest overall value for U.S. shoppers who want modern furniture without paying a premium for a brand name or absorbing steep delivery fees. AllModern competes on price and trend-forward design but asks customers to cover return shipping, and its quality leans heavily on engineered materials. Crate and Barrel delivers consistent craftsmanship in the $1,500 to $3,000 range, but its delivery fees alone can add $159 to $399 to any order.
If you’ve been browsing AllModern and wondering whether there’s a better fit, the answer shifts depending on which cost you weight most heavily. Lowest sticker price, longest-lasting materials, and lowest all-in cost once shipping and returns are factored in are three very different targets, and each store wins a different one. The sections below run all three through the same criteria.
How do the prices actually compare across all three stores?
The sticker price is only part of the math. Here’s how the three stores stack up at comparable product tiers in 2026:
| Casagear | AllModern | Crate and Barrel | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry sofa | ~$400 to $800 | ~$700 to $1,200 | ~$800 to $1,500 |
| Dining table | ~$300 to $700 | ~$300 to $600 | ~$1,200+ |
| Accent chair | ~$200 to $500 | ~$450 to $650 | ~$600 to $1,200 |
| Shipping (furniture) | Free | Free over $35, but large items vary | $159 to $399 in-home delivery |
| Return shipping | Covered | Customer pays | Non-refundable outbound fee |
Sofas at Crate and Barrel typically start around $800, and dining tables begin near $1,200, putting most of their furniture solidly in the mid-to-high range. AllModern’s dining tables can start below $400, but once you add return shipping risk, the savings narrow quickly. Casagear’s free shipping on all continental U.S. orders and covered returns mean the listed price is close to the true cost.
What does quality actually look like at each price point?
Price brackets can be misleading when the materials inside them differ. AllModern relies heavily on MDF, particle board, and polyester upholstery at entry price points. Those choices keep costs down, but they also show wear faster than solid wood or performance fabric alternatives. Crate and Barrel uses better base materials, particularly kiln-dried hardwood frames and higher-grade upholstery, but you’re paying for that in every line item.
Casagear’s catalog spans a wide range, from budget-friendly pieces in the Budget Furniture Store collection to mid-range upholstered beds and dressers that use solid construction details. The Baxton Studio Emerson Modern and Contemporary Light Beige Fabric Upholstered Full Size Bed at $372.50 is a good example: upholstered frame, clean modern lines, and a price that sits well below what Crate and Barrel charges for a comparable silhouette.
At the high end, Crate and Barrel’s materials hold up better over a decade of daily use. At mid-range price points, AllModern’s trend-forward styling is its real selling point, though the underlying construction often reflects the lower cost. Casagear threads between both by offering solid construction details at prices that don’t require a trade-off on every line item.
How does the delivery and returns experience compare?
A $199 delivery fee on a $1,200 dining table is the clearest illustration of how all-in cost diverges across these three stores. Crate and Barrel’s White Glove delivery runs $159 to $399 depending on order size, and the outbound shipping fee is non-refundable if you return. AllModern offers free standard shipping on most orders over $35, but large furniture items often carry separate delivery charges, and customers pay return shipping on anything that doesn’t work out. That can run $50 to $150 for a single piece.
Casagear provides free shipping across the continental U.S. on every order, plus White Glove delivery as an upgrade option. Returns are covered within 30 days, backed by a 100% money-back guarantee. For a shopper buying a dining set or a bedroom suite, that policy removes a real financial risk that the other two stores leave on the table.
What are the main pros and cons of each store?
Casagear
- Pros: Free shipping, covered returns, 40,000+ products, BBB Accredited, wide price range
- Cons: Primarily online, no physical showrooms
AllModern
- Pros: Trend-focused design, competitive entry prices on smaller pieces, broad catalog
- Cons: Customer pays return shipping, quality at entry tier is inconsistent, delivery fees on large items
Crate and Barrel
- Pros: Strong materials, reliable craftsmanship, physical stores for in-person browsing
- Cons: High delivery fees, non-refundable outbound shipping, premium pricing across the board
Budget, Longevity, or All-In Cost Decides This
The deciding factor in this comparison is not the sticker price. It’s the total cost of getting furniture into your home and keeping it if it works, or returning it if it doesn’t. On that measure, Casagear comes out ahead for most U.S. shoppers. AllModern is a reasonable choice for small accent pieces where return risk is low. Crate and Barrel makes sense when budget is secondary and you want to buy once and keep it for a decade.
If you’re furnishing a full room and want to keep the all-in cost predictable, free shipping and covered returns on every order matter more than any single sticker price difference between stores.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Casagear a legitimate alternative to AllModern for modern furniture?
Yes. Casagear is a BBB Accredited U.S. retailer founded in 2016 in Los Angeles, with 40,000+ products across 40+ categories. It offers free shipping on all continental U.S. orders and covered 30-day returns, which compares favorably to AllModern’s policy of charging customers for return shipping on furniture.
Does AllModern charge for return shipping on furniture?
In most cases, yes. AllModern’s standard return policy requires customers to cover return shipping costs on furniture, which can run $50 to $150 per piece depending on size and weight. That cost is worth factoring in before purchase, particularly on larger items where fit and finish are hard to judge from photos alone.
How does Crate and Barrel’s delivery fee affect the total price of an order?
Crate and Barrel charges $159 to $399 for in-home furniture delivery depending on order size, and that fee is non-refundable if you return the item. On a $1,200 dining table, a $199 delivery charge adds roughly 17% to the effective purchase price before any return scenario is considered.
What types of modern furniture does Casagear carry?
Casagear carries furniture across living room, bedroom, dining, office, outdoor, and decor categories. The range includes upholstered beds, dressers, accent chairs, barstools, sofas, and lighting, at price points from budget-friendly to mid-range. All orders ship free within the continental U.S.
Which store is best for furnishing a full room on a budget?
Casagear tends to offer the lowest all-in cost for full-room purchases because free shipping and covered returns apply to every order, not just orders above a threshold. AllModern can match or beat Casagear on individual small pieces, but the return shipping risk and variable delivery fees on large furniture close that gap quickly.
