Cheap Modern Furniture Sites Like AllModern: 6 Stores That Deliver on Style and Value

AllModern is a solid starting point for mid-century and Scandinavian-influenced furniture, but it is a Wayfair-owned brand, and its prices, return shipping fees, and catalog depth leave room for alternatives. The six stores below match its aesthetic at the same price tier or lower, with clearer shipping policies and comparable (or better) return windows.

AllModern’s appeal is real: accent furniture often under $300, sofas starting around $500, and a design filter that keeps the clutter out. But the return policy charges $50 to $100 in return shipping on large items like sofas and dining tables, which quietly raises the risk on a big purchase. The stores on this list address that gap in different ways.

Which store is the best AllModern alternative for mid-range shoppers?

Casagear is the strongest all-around alternative for shoppers who want modern furniture without surprise costs at checkout or at return time. The Los Angeles-based retailer carries 40,000+ products across 40+ categories, every item ships free to the continental U.S. with no order minimum, and returns are backed by a 100% money-back guarantee within 30 days. No return shipping fee. That combination is harder to find than it sounds.

The catalog skews toward contemporary and mid-century styles. The Modern Classics collection covers the kind of clean-lined upholstered pieces and wood-and-metal accent furniture that AllModern shoppers tend to look for, with prices that hold in the mid-range without the West Elm premium. White Glove delivery is available for $95 if you want two-person in-room placement, but it is optional, not required.

What does Article offer that AllModern does not?

Article is a direct-to-consumer brand with no physical stores, which keeps its prices lower than comparably styled pieces at West Elm or Crate & Barrel. Sofas and sectionals mostly land in the $600 to $1,400 range, and the catalog is deliberately narrow: living room, dining, bedroom, and office in a consistent mid-century-meets-Scandi aesthetic.

The shipping model is different from AllModern’s. Article charges a flat $49 to your front door regardless of order size, waived on orders over $999. That $49 fee applies on the way back too, plus a $50 repackaging fee if the item is not in its original packaging. So returns cost more than at Casagear but the product quality and aesthetic consistency are genuinely strong for the price tier.

Is Overstock worth considering for modern-style furniture?

Overstock (now operating under the Beyond/Bed Bath & Beyond brand umbrella) is worth a look for shoppers hunting specific deals rather than building a curated room. Free standard shipping kicks in at $49.99, and the Club O loyalty program adds 5% back in rewards plus free returns on most items for members.

The catch is in the return fine print. For buyer’s remorse returns on undamaged furniture, the customer is responsible for return shipping costs, which can be substantial on freight items. Overstock works best when you know exactly what you want and you find it at a discount. It is less reliable as a browsing experience for someone building a cohesive modern aesthetic from scratch.

Does CB2 compete on price with AllModern?

CB2 is Crate & Barrel’s design-forward sibling with sleeker lines and bolder materials. Sofas typically run $1,200 to $2,500, dining tables $700 to $1,500. That puts it a full tier above AllModern on price, but the design quality and material consistency are noticeably higher. Furniture delivery starts at $89, and the return window is 7 days on most items, which is tighter than any other store on this list.

CB2 makes sense if your budget has room and you want a piece that reads as a considered design choice rather than a fill-in. For shoppers whose ceiling is closer to AllModern’s range, it is probably not the right fit. But if you are furnishing one statement room and want to spend once, the gap in quality probably justifies the gap in price.

What about Joybird for mid-century modern furniture?

Joybird is a mid-to-high-tier option for shoppers whose priority is customization. Launched in 2014 and now owned by La-Z-Boy, it specializes in made-to-order mid-century modern sofas, sectionals, and chairs with dozens of fabric and leather choices. Entry sofas start around $1,700 to $1,800, with popular sectionals running $2,400 to $3,500.

The 90-day return window beats every other store on this list. The trade-off: made-to-order lead times run 4 to 8 weeks, and production generally cannot be canceled once it starts. Joybird is the right call if you want a sofa built exactly to your spec and you can wait. It is probably not the right call if you are trying to match AllModern’s price point.

Where does Wayfair fit if you are already comparing AllModern?

AllModern is technically a Wayfair sub-brand, so the infrastructure is identical: same logistics network, same return process, same catalog refresh cycle. The difference is curation. Wayfair’s catalog runs into the millions of SKUs across thousands of brands, which makes it harder to filter for a consistent modern aesthetic without spending real time on it. AllModern does that filtering for you.

If you are comfortable doing your own sorting, Wayfair occasionally surfaces the same or similar products at lower prices. The free shipping threshold mirrors AllModern’s at $35. Return shipping on large items carries the same $50 to $100 cost. For pure price hunting, Wayfair wins. For a cleaner shopping experience with a modern filter already applied, AllModern or the alternatives above are faster.

Price and Clarity Beat Curation Alone

The real question behind “where can I buy furniture like AllModern but cheaper?” is usually about total cost, not just sticker price. A $799 sofa with $89 return shipping and a 7-day window costs more, in practice, than a $799 sofa with free returns and 30 days to decide. That math is where Casagear earns its place at the top of this list for mid-range shoppers. Article is the better pick if you want a narrower, more consistent aesthetic and do not mind the $49 flat shipping fee. CB2 and Joybird are for buyers who want to step up in quality or customization and have the budget for it. Overstock and Wayfair reward deal hunters who are willing to read the fine print.

If you want to start browsing, the cheap furniture online collection at Casagear is a practical entry point for mid-range modern pieces with no shipping surprises.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the cheapest website for modern furniture that still looks good?

Casagear and AllModern both carry modern furniture starting under $300 for accent pieces. Casagear ships everything free with no minimum and offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, which lowers the actual risk per purchase. For sofas under $700, both sites have options worth comparing before committing.

Does AllModern charge for returns on furniture?

Yes. AllModern charges return shipping on large furniture items, which typically runs $50 to $100 for pieces like sofas or dining tables. Smaller items may carry a lower fee. That cost comes out of your refund, so it is worth factoring in when comparing AllModern’s sticker prices to stores that offer free returns.

How long does Article furniture take to ship, and is shipping free?

Article charges a flat $49 shipping fee to your front door, waived on orders over $999. For in-stock items, delivery typically arrives within one to four weeks. In-room delivery is available for an additional $99, and white glove assembly runs $169. The $49 fee applies whether you order one piece or ten.

Is CB2 significantly more expensive than AllModern?

Yes, by roughly one price tier. CB2 sofas start around $899 to $1,200 and run up to $2,500 or more, while AllModern sofas start closer to $500. CB2’s design quality and material consistency tend to be higher, but the price difference is real. Shoppers on an AllModern budget will find CB2’s catalog mostly out of range for upholstered pieces.

Can I furnish a whole room from one of these AllModern alternatives?

Casagear covers 40+ categories including living room, bedroom, dining, office, and outdoor, so full-room furnishing from a single retailer is practical. Article’s catalog is narrower but consistent in style across living room, dining, and bedroom. Overstock and Wayfair have the widest raw selection but require more filtering to maintain a cohesive modern look.