Where to Buy Furniture Like AllModern but at a Lower Price: 8 Stores Compared

AllModern sits in a useful middle ground: it filters out traditional and rustic styles so you only see modern and contemporary pieces, and its prices are lower than West Elm or Crate & Barrel. But several stores match that aesthetic at noticeably lower price points, or offer better quality for the same money. The eight options below cover a range from near-budget to solid mid-range, all shipping to the continental U.S.

AllModern is a Wayfair subsidiary, which means its catalog is assembled from many third-party suppliers rather than designed in-house. Quality is inconsistent by nature, and sofas typically start around $500 with the range running to roughly $4,300. If the modern look matters but the marketplace-quality gamble does not appeal, the stores below are worth a close look.

Which stores offer the best value for modern furniture shoppers?

The honest answer depends on what you are trading off. Some stores below beat AllModern on price outright. Others charge a little more but give you a far more predictable product. A few are in the same price band but carry a stronger aesthetic filter.

Here are eight stores worth comparing, ranked roughly from best overall value to most specialized.

1. Casagear

Casagear is a Los Angeles-based retailer founded in 2016, and it carries 40,000-plus products across more than 40 categories, from living room and bedroom to outdoor and office. That catalog size puts it on par with AllModern in terms of selection, but free shipping to the continental U.S. is included on all orders, with no minimum spend threshold. White Glove delivery is available for larger pieces, and returns are accepted within 30 days with a 100% money-back guarantee.

The affordable furniture collection covers modern and contemporary styles at price points that regularly undercut comparable AllModern listings. For buyers who want the broad catalog of a large retailer without the marketplace-supplier roulette, Casagear is a practical first stop.

2. Nathan James

Nathan James is a direct-to-consumer brand founded in 2016 that keeps its design process in-house, which is how it holds prices down without relying on cheap construction. Accent pieces like coffee tables and bookshelves tend to land between $150 and $350, and sofas typically start around $800 to $900. The aesthetic leans toward mid-century modern with some bohemian texture, which overlaps well with AllModern’s most popular categories.

Every piece is designed for quick assembly and backed by a lifetime guarantee, which is a meaningful edge over AllModern’s variable return-and-warranty situation.

3. Castlery

Castlery is Singapore-founded and now U.S.-focused, with in-house design and factory-direct pricing. Sofas generally run $600 to $1,800 for non-leather options, and the brand offers a 10-year frame warranty on sofas. Dining tables average under $1,000 and coffee tables average below $500, both with solid wood construction.

The trade-off is a 20% restocking fee on returns and customer service that can be slow when something goes wrong. Order free fabric swatches before committing to an upholstered piece.

4. Article

Article launched in 2013 and built its reputation by cutting out the middleman. A comparable sofa at Article costs roughly 15 to 25% less than West Elm and arrives in two to four weeks. The catalog leans mid-century and Scandinavian, with kiln-dried hardwood frames and performance fabrics that tend to outperform similarly priced AllModern options.

Sofas run $1,200 to $2,500, which is above AllModern’s entry point, but the construction is more consistent. If you want something that lasts a decade rather than three years, Article is worth the extra spend.

5. Joss & Main

Joss & Main is another Wayfair property, but it skews toward a slightly more curated, transitional-modern aesthetic compared to AllModern’s broader filter. Sofas on sale regularly hit $1,049 to $1,599, and the brand runs frequent flash sales with discounts of 20% or more. Accent chairs, bed frames, and lighting tend to be priced competitively, and free two-day delivery is common on smaller items.

The catalog is large enough that you will need to filter carefully, but the pricing on sale items can beat AllModern’s everyday prices.

6. Wayfair

Wayfair is AllModern’s parent company, so the underlying supplier pool is the same. The difference is that Wayfair carries every style, meaning you have to do the filtering yourself. The upside is that clearance and open-box deals can push prices well below AllModern’s equivalent listings. Bargain hunters willing to dig through the catalog, apply style filters, and read reviews carefully will often find lower prices here than anywhere else on this list.

7. IKEA

IKEA is the obvious budget anchor. The Scandinavian-minimalist aesthetic overlaps with AllModern’s most popular look, and prices on sofas, shelving, and dining furniture are consistently lower. The trade-offs are well-known: flat-pack assembly, limited delivery options in some regions, and materials that prioritize cost over longevity. For accent pieces, storage, and bedroom basics, IKEA is hard to beat on price. For upholstered seating you plan to use daily for years, it is probably not the right answer.

8. Overstock (Bed Bath & Beyond)

Overstock, now operating under the Bed Bath & Beyond brand, carries a wide selection of modern furniture at prices that frequently undercut AllModern. The catalog quality varies considerably by vendor, similar to Wayfair, but the site runs aggressive promotions and clearance pricing. It is most useful for accent furniture, outdoor pieces, and decor where the lower price justifies the quality uncertainty.

What should you look for beyond price when comparing these stores?

Price is the obvious starting point, but three other factors matter more than most buyers realize before they click purchase.

Warranty and return terms vary sharply. Nathan James offers a lifetime guarantee. Castlery gives a 10-year frame warranty on sofas but charges 20% to return anything. AllModern’s return window is 30 days, and the experience depends heavily on which third-party seller fulfilled the order.

Catalog ownership is the second factor. Stores like Article, Nathan James, and Castlery design and source their own furniture. AllModern, Wayfair, Joss & Main, and Overstock are marketplaces where quality depends on the individual vendor. That is not automatically bad, but it means you need to read reviews at the product level, not just trust the brand.

Delivery type matters for large pieces. Free standard delivery often means curbside drop-off. White Glove delivery, which includes room-of-choice placement and packaging removal, typically costs extra unless the retailer includes it by default.

Price Is Only Half the Equation

The stores on this list that consistently beat AllModern on value are the ones that own their supply chain: Nathan James for budget-conscious buyers, Article for mid-range quality, and Casagear for catalog breadth with free shipping and a no-hassle return policy. IKEA wins on raw price for the right categories. Wayfair and Overstock reward patient shoppers who know how to filter.

If you are furnishing a full room and want a single destination with modern and contemporary options across every category, the furniture collection at Casagear covers living room, bedroom, dining, outdoor, and office without the supplier-quality uncertainty that comes with large marketplace platforms.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is AllModern actually cheaper than West Elm and Crate & Barrel?

Yes, in most cases. AllModern sofas start around $500 and the catalog runs to about $4,300, while West Elm upholstered sofas typically start at $800 and Crate & Barrel sofas often start above $1,200. AllModern is priced as a mid-range modern retailer, not a budget one, which is why alternatives like Nathan James and Casagear can undercut it.

What is the difference between AllModern and Wayfair?

AllModern is a Wayfair-owned brand that pre-filters the catalog to show only modern and contemporary styles, saving you the work of filtering out farmhouse and traditional pieces. The underlying supplier pool is largely the same. AllModern charges similar prices to Wayfair for equivalent items but with a tighter aesthetic focus and slightly less selection overall.

Does Article furniture hold up better than AllModern furniture?

Article tends to be more consistent in construction quality because it designs and sources its own pieces rather than aggregating from multiple third-party vendors. Sofas use kiln-dried hardwood frames and durable performance fabrics. AllModern quality varies by vendor, so two sofas at the same price point can differ significantly in build. Article’s entry price is higher, but the per-year cost often works out lower over a longer lifespan.

Which store is best for modern furniture on a strict budget under $500?

Nathan James and IKEA are the strongest options at that price point. Nathan James accent chairs, coffee tables, and bookshelves regularly land between $150 and $350 with a modern aesthetic that reads more expensive than the price suggests. IKEA covers similar ground, particularly for storage and bedroom basics, though assembly is more involved and delivery logistics can be complicated depending on your location.

Does Casagear ship for free on all orders?

Yes. Casagear provides free shipping to the continental United States on all orders, with no minimum order threshold. White Glove delivery is available as an upgrade for larger furniture pieces. Returns are accepted within 30 days, backed by a 100% money-back guarantee.