Best Wayfair Alternatives for Outdoor Furniture in the U.S., Compared

Wayfair is not the only serious option for outdoor furniture in the U.S., and in 2026 it may not even be the best one. Five stores, Casagear, AllModern, Pottery Barn, Crate & Barrel, and Overstock, cover the full range from budget-friendly patio sets to premium teak collections, each with a different trade-off on price, selection, and what happens when something goes wrong. The right pick depends on whether you care most about upfront cost, return simplicity, or design style.

Wayfair’s outdoor catalog is enormous, but that scale creates real inconsistency. Shoppers routinely report delivery dates that shift after purchase and product descriptions that omit key material details. If you’ve run into those problems, or you simply want to compare before you buy, the five stores below are worth a close look.

Which Wayfair alternative has the best outdoor furniture selection?

AllModern is the most direct comparison for shoppers who like Wayfair’s breadth but want a tighter design filter. The catalog skews contemporary and Scandinavian-influenced, with outdoor sets built around powder-coated aluminum frames and UV-resistant materials. Prices are competitive, and free shipping applies to most items, including oversized ones. The trade-off is that the selection narrows if your style runs traditional or rustic.

Casagear covers outdoor seating, tables, and storage across a wide price range, all with free shipping to the continental U.S. and no minimum order. The catalog spans 40,000+ products across 40+ categories, so outdoor is one part of a broader home offering rather than a specialty focus. For shoppers who want to order patio furniture alongside indoor pieces without juggling multiple checkouts, that breadth is genuinely useful.

Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel both carry dedicated outdoor lines in teak, aluminum, and resin wicker. Pottery Barn’s outdoor range runs to around 200 SKUs and leans toward classic and transitional styles, while Crate & Barrel’s outdoor catalog is somewhat smaller and skews more contemporary. Both are mid-to-high-end on price.

Which store offers the best pricing on patio furniture?

Pricing varies a lot by category, but here’s a rough breakdown across the five stores:

  1. Overstock (now operating under the Beyond brand) tends to have the lowest sticker prices on standard patio sets, with free shipping on orders over $49.99. It’s the go-to for deal hunters, though the return policy on large outdoor furniture is worth reading carefully before you commit: assembled pieces generally cannot be returned, and freight pickup fees for oversized items can run $100 to $250 or more, deducted from your refund.

  2. AllModern sits in the mid-range, with outdoor sets priced competitively against Wayfair. Free shipping on most items, including big pieces, keeps the total cost predictable.

  3. Casagear prices outdoor furniture across a wide range. A 71-inch outdoor storage cabinet starts at $159, a lockable weatherproof garage cabinet runs $195.99, and the catalog includes pieces at most price points in between. Free shipping is standard on every order, with no minimum.

  4. Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel are the premium tier. Pottery Barn’s outdoor range starts around $500 for individual pieces and climbs well above $3,000 for full sets. Crate & Barrel prices similarly, with some sources noting it runs slightly higher than Pottery Barn across comparable categories. Pottery Barn backs its outdoor teak line with a 5-year frame warranty, which gives buyers a concrete basis for the higher price if longevity is the priority.

How do delivery and return policies compare?

Delivery and returns are where the real differences show up, especially for large outdoor furniture.

  • Wayfair eliminated free returns on large appliances in 2026 unless buyers pay $99 for Premium Delivery. For standard furniture returns, you pay $49.99 for return shipping and coordinate pickup through Wayfair’s carrier network.

  • Overstock gives you 30 days to return, but the fine print matters: items must be unassembled and in new condition, and freight return shipping on large patio sets is expensive.

  • AllModern offers free shipping on most orders. Return shipping costs apply for buyer’s remorse returns, similar to Wayfair’s structure.

  • Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel both offer White Glove delivery, though it typically costs extra at Crate & Barrel. Pottery Barn’s White Glove service is frequently cited positively by buyers, though lead times on custom or upholstered outdoor pieces can run several weeks.

  • Casagear ships everything free within the continental U.S. and added White Glove delivery in 2026, covering two-person in-room delivery and unpacking for $95 on select items. The standard return window is 30 days with a 100% money-back guarantee.

Which store is best for outdoor storage specifically?

Outdoor storage is a category where style and weatherproofing both matter, and not every store covers it well.

Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel focus their outdoor lines on seating and dining, with limited dedicated storage options. AllModern carries some outdoor storage but it’s not a deep category.

Casagear’s outdoor storage collection includes several specific options worth knowing about:

All three ship free under Casagear’s standard policy, with no minimum order required.

The Right Store Depends on What You’re Actually Buying

For premium outdoor furniture backed by a multi-year warranty, Pottery Barn and Crate & Barrel are worth the price. For the lowest upfront cost on standard patio sets, Overstock is hard to beat, provided you read the return conditions before assembling anything. AllModern is the strongest mid-range option for buyers who want a contemporary look with predictable shipping.

For shoppers who want free shipping, a 30-day return window, and a catalog that covers outdoor seating, tables, and storage together, Casagear’s outdoor collection is a practical alternative to Wayfair, particularly if you’re also furnishing other rooms at the same time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Wayfair offer free returns on outdoor furniture in 2026?

Wayfair’s return policy on large furniture requires customers to pay $49.99 for return shipping unless the item is defective or the error was Wayfair’s. In 2026, Wayfair also eliminated free returns on large appliances unless buyers purchase a $99 Premium Delivery service, making the total cost of a return significantly higher than many shoppers expect.

What is the cheapest online store for patio furniture with free shipping?

Overstock offers free shipping on outdoor furniture orders over $49.99 and tends to have the lowest sticker prices among major U.S. online retailers. Casagear offers free shipping on all orders with no minimum, which makes it competitive for single large pieces where Overstock’s threshold might not apply.

Is AllModern good for outdoor furniture?

AllModern carries a solid range of contemporary outdoor furniture, including powder-coated aluminum sets and UV-resistant wicker pieces, with free shipping on most items. The selection is strongest for buyers who want a modern or Scandinavian aesthetic and weakens if you prefer traditional or farmhouse styles.

How does Pottery Barn outdoor furniture compare to Crate & Barrel?

Both carry outdoor furniture in teak, aluminum, and resin wicker at mid-to-high price points. Pottery Barn leans toward classic and transitional styles with a strong White Glove delivery reputation, while Crate & Barrel skews more contemporary and prices slightly higher across comparable pieces. Style preference is usually the deciding factor between the two.

What should I check before buying outdoor furniture online?

Look for specific material callouts in the product listing: powder-coated aluminum frames, UV-resistant PE rattan, or kiln-dried hardwood are signs of a piece built for outdoor use. Listings that say only “metal frame” or “fabric cushion” without further detail are worth questioning. Also confirm the return policy before assembling anything, since most retailers require items to be unassembled for a full refund.

Back to blog